Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Review: Soul Sworn by Kate Dylan

Soul Sworn
(Soul Sworn Saga #1)
Publication Date: November 17, 2026
Hardcover, 336 pages, Delacorte Press
Genres: Adult, Romantasy, LGBTQ+

The thrilling first book of a steamy duology from Sunday Times bestselling author, Kate Dylan.
 
Two ruthless assassins. One deadly romance.
 
 Talia Atwater is a reaper, an elite assassin who uses her looks, her charms, and her rare ability to sense lies to rid clients of their sworn enemy: the person destined to kill their soulmate. For Talia, love is just another way to die.
 
Cain Hawthorne was raised to be a weapon. Bound to a powerful religious order, he hunts rogue reapers in the name of the Gods. Duty is everything. Love is forbidden. All that matters is protecting their fated ties.
 
So when Talia takes a job that threatens fate, Cain is sent to stop her.
 
But in a world where every soul is marked—for love and death—the line between mission and desire begins to blur.
 
 As secrets unravel and attraction ignites, Talia and Cain are pulled into a dangerous game of seduction, secrets, and lies. And the closer they get to the truth, the clearer it becomes:
 
They were never meant to fall in love. They were meant to destroy each other.
 
SOUL SWORN is a dark, addictive romantasy filled with assassins, blood magic, and a sizzling enemies-to-lovers romance that will leave readers breathless.

My Review

Soul Sworn had me in a chokehold. I could not stop reading once I started. I think it put me in a book hangover too. It took a while to recover and nothing else sounded nearly as good after. I was expecting to like this one, simply because it sounded right up my alley with a badass/morally gray FMC and a conflicted, somewhat naive MMC. What I wasn't expecting was to fly through it in a very short amount of time. But I did. Now, I have to wait oh-so-long for book two. Ugh.

The main female character, Talia Atwater, is not a good person, technically. Maybe. She's a reaper, which means she kills people who will end up killing someone else's soulmate. That's the whole point of the story, deliberating if it's okay to take someone's life if you know that person will end up taking another's life in the future. It's the age-old morality question that there is no perfect answer for. Talia is also taking these jobs for her sister, so it adds in another morality question about doing bad things to keep you and your family alive. I really liked Talia. I think she was conflicted, jaded, feisty, sexy, and powerful all in one.

As for Cain, the MMC, he's basically a monk warrior who kills people because his parish tells him to. While I'm not super excited for religious characters in my fictional stories (fantasy or otherwise), Cain did have me invested. Poor boy was going through it. Also, a small thing, I really loved that Talia was older than Cain. We need older FMCs in romantasy, even if it's only by a few years.

 For the worldbuilding, I think it's fascinating that Kate Dylan kind of took the concept of fanfiction soulmate storylines and put them into a unique fantasy world. I'm not saying the author purposefully did this or even if that was her inspiration. I honestly don't know if that was her intent. But to me, the story reminded me of my favorite soulmate AUs. The soulmate and sworn enemy ring bands really contributed to that. As for the magical powers, the witch element is really cool. There are different types of witches that all have proper names, but they can basically be described as lie detectors, seers, and a bloody version of email. That's basically Cain's power, sending emails through his own flesh and blood. Overall, it was super easy to follow and I had a good time immersing myself into the story. The sexuality-fluid world was fantastic too!

 Honestly, my biggest complaint for the book is that the spicy scenes were glazed over at some points. It was pretty disappointing. I wanted more! The buildup was there. I just needed the payoff. It was kind of the same for the ending in general. Things were nicely paced at first, and then towards the end, things went too quickly. I think it needed another fifty pages at the end to keep the pace and tension. And while I am very excited for book two, I didn't feel the impact of the two major cliffhangers like I wanted to because of the fast pacing. I will be reading the sequel, though. You can count on that.

All in all, I think fans of the witchy, forbidden love elements of Serpent & Dove and The Crimson Moth duology, as well as Susan Dennard's Truthwitch, will devour this book. But, since it's definitely an adult romantasy, I think some more mature comp titles based on vibes, worldbuilding, and the author;s writing style would include Fall of Ruin and Wrath by Jennifer L. Armentrout, Silvercloak by L.K. Steven, What Fury Brings by Tricia Levenseller, and Danielle L. Jensen's romantasy books.


*Note: I received a copy of this book to review from the publisher via NetGalley. This in no way affected my opinion/review.

No comments:

Post a Comment

I LOVE your comments! And I do read all of them so keep at it! Thanks for visiting!